28. February 2023
Talks between pension funds and the state have yielded nothing
A meeting of twenty pension funds, the largest holders of ÍL-sjóður bonds, has concluded that, under current circumstances, there is no basis for negotiations with the Ministry of Finance regarding settlement of the fund's obligations. Representatives of the Ministry have not met the pension funds' demand for full performance by the Icelandic state in its efforts towards a possible settlement.
The Icelandic state bears unlimited liability for all obligations of ÍL-sjóður. The Minister of Finance's plan for winding up and settling the fund's obligations without regard to future interest payments amounts to a curtailment of property rights that is contrary to the provisions of the Constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights. This is set out in detailed and well-reasoned legal opinions from LOGOS Legal Services and from Róbert Spanó, former President of the European Court of Human Rights. The Minister of Finance's proposals for a settlement that does not involve full performance by the Icelandic state are therefore unacceptable.
The Minister of Finance's answers in Alþingi on the matter last week are surprising, in particular the remarks suggesting that no agreement on a curtailment of assets is being sought. The announced measures relating to the winding-up of ÍL-sjóður, which aim to significantly reduce the Icelandic state's financial obligations through legislation if no agreement is reached, would, under current circumstances, lead to tens of billions of krónur in losses for the pension funds and, in turn, for the public in the form of lost pension rights. It is clear that any such measures would be tested before the courts.
The pension funds have extensive statutory duties towards their principals, the fund members. These duties preclude entering into an agreement of the kind envisaged by the Ministry of Finance. As long as the pension funds' fundamental demand for full performance is not met, negotiations with the Ministry of Finance serve no purpose. There is full consensus among the funds on this point.