16. November 2010
Operating costs of Icelandic and Danish pension funds the lowest in the OECD.
The operating costs of pension funds in Iceland and Denmark are lower than in any other member state of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). The latest figures on this date from 2007, and the operating costs of Icelandic and Danish pension funds then corresponded to 0.2% of the funds' total assets. The ratio in Finland, Germany and Austria was 0.4%, while it was highest in the Czech Republic, at 1.4%, as shown in the accompanying information from the OECD.
The National Association of Pension Funds considers it necessary to point this out in light of claims made by Ragnar Þór Ingólfsson, a board member of the Reykjavík Commercial Workers' Union (VR), about the “absurd” operating costs of pension funds in Iceland. He is a regular guest on Silfur Egils, is generally outspoken about pension funds and their operations, and at times treats the facts rather freely in his arguments.
Ragnar Þór is now harshly critical of the funds' operating costs and also believes it would be right to merge all Icelanders' pension funds into a single fund, which would presumably then be under state control. That is certainly a viewpoint in its own right, but it is unlikely to find much support among fund members within the general pension fund system.
The fact is, and this claim can easily be verified, that the Icelandic pension fund system is cited as a model in many parts of the world. It is also noted that its operating costs are among the lowest known.
This is also an opportunity to point out that the number of pension funds has fallen sharply in recent years. About two decades ago there were around 90 in total, but 31 funds now receive premiums, and the five largest control 60% of the total assets of the nation's pension funds. The ten largest funds control around 80% of the assets of all pension funds.
The number of pension funds in Iceland will fall further still. For example, four pension funds have recently merged into the Pension Rights Collection Fund, and among the smallest funds currently operating are several municipal funds that do not accept new members. These will therefore automatically cease to exist in the coming years.
Information from the OECD on the operating costs of pension funds in member states, presented graphically with Icelandic text, can be viewed by clicking here.
can be viewed by clicking here.