5. December 2014
National consensus or a declaration of war?
A smaller contribution to equalising the disability burden reduces the pensions of labourers and seamen.
In an international comparison, we can truly claim to have a strong pension system in Iceland. A system designed for the sustainability of each fund member having contributed to building up a fund that secures a pension once working life ends. This is no less valuable when considering that the nation is steadily ageing, meaning that fewer working hands will be available to sustain the welfare system in the future. The new budget bill proposes reducing the contribution towards equalising the disability burden of pension funds for labourers and seamen, which means a direct cut to the pensions of these groups. These proposals run counter to all the goals of national consensus that the government claims to support.
The strong pension system we have, however, did not come about on its own and required both sacrifices and conflict in the labour market. It has taken a joint effort by labour market parties, giving up part of general pay increases in previous wage agreements, to secure a reliable pension for later years.
Since current pension rights were negotiated in wage agreements, the largest pension funds also reflect the occupational groups covered by those agreements. The proportion of the disability component is accordingly higher in pension funds whose occupational groups are more exposed to increased risk of accidents or workload, such as general labourers and seamen.
We have always maintained that the increased risk from accidents and workload in certain occupations was a responsibility of society. To meet this obligation of the state, a government statement at the end of 2005 on equalising the disability burden accompanied one of the premises of the wage agreements signed in 2006, and this was enshrined in law by Alþingi a year later. In this way, the authorities in effect accepted this responsibility.
The budget bill currently under consideration proposes abolishing these annual payments intended to equalise the disability pension burden of the pension funds. If these proposals go ahead, the premises of previous wage agreements will have collapsed, and one may also ask whether the authorities are, in doing so, throwing down the gauntlet for the upcoming wage negotiations.
Messages have been heard, including from the government, that a national consensus needs to be considered in the coming wage negotiations. Does the government consider the abolition of the disability contribution to be a good contribution to a national consensus, meaning that labourers and seamen should give up part of their pay increases to cover the sacrifice of working in hazardous occupations?
It is also clear that this proposed change will not equalise the pension rights of public sector employees and private sector employees, but will instead increase this disparity, as public sector employees have any cuts to their funds compensated by taxpayers, as has been the case.
It is also worth noting that, at the same time as the authorities see reason to cut the pension rights of those who have the least, there are no proposals in sight for how to address the enormous deficit facing the pension funds of public sector employees.
If the government's plans to abolish the disability contribution go ahead, it will fall to the Board of Directors of Gildi Pension Fund to cut fund members' rights by up to 4.5% over the next five years.
These are cold comfort that do not sit at all well with the goal of a national consensus in the labour market.
Harpa Ólafsdóttir, Chair of the Board of Directors of Gildi
Reykjavík, 4 December 2014