31. October 2013

Incorrect claim about pension funds' payments to LBI

The online publication Kjarninn claims today that the Supreme Court's ruling acquitting Norvik hf. of NBI's claims for payment under derivative agreements implies that, among other things, the pension funds unnecessarily paid LBI large sums. This conclusion is incorrect. The grounds of the ruling did not apply to the pension funds' agreements, which could never have argued that they considered the bank to have waived its claims under the agreements:

  • The ruling in the Norvik hf. case concerns combined interest rate and currency swap agreements that were to run for 2-3 years beyond the financial crisis. The ruling is based primarily on the finding that the bank's failure to make payments under the interest-swap portion of the agreements gave the defendant reasonable grounds to understand a notice, which it and many others received from the bank, as meaning that the agreements had been cancelled. The bank's inaction reinforced that understanding. The Court places emphasis on the duration of the agreements in this regard.
  • Most of the pension funds' derivative agreements with LBI were forward currency swap agreements with a term of a few months. Most fell due in 2008, with a few in the first months of 2009. These agreements did not call for visible performance on the bank's part in the same way as Norvik's agreements. The ruling would therefore not have set a precedent for those agreements.
  • The pension funds were jointly engaged in discussions with the authorities and all the banks about the status of the currency agreements as early as October 2008 and continuing afterwards. The scale of the pension funds' dealings with the banks was such that their management and that of the failed banks were bound to discuss settlement matters soon after the banks' collapse, and to test collection or negotiation. The pension funds therefore never had the opportunity to 'benefit' from inaction on the banks' part, as was found in the Norvik case, such that they would have had cause to assume the bank had waived its claims under the agreements.
  • The premise of the ruling is that the bank's counterparty received the notice in question. If that did not happen, the question of the ruling's precedent does not arise. Some funds are likely to have received the notice while others did not. For the reasons given above, however, they could in no case have relied on the same arguments as were made in the ruling in the Norvik hf. case.
  • The funds obtained numerous legal opinions on the binding validity of the currency agreements and on the basis for their settlement. Strong arguments were put forward that the agreements should be set aside due to various forms of market manipulation by the banks prior to the crash. It was the unanimous conclusion of those the funds consulted that litigation over the validity of the agreements would be risky, and that it would therefore be prudent to seek settlements to limit the funds' losses as much as possible. That course was chosen, and the settlements reached succeeded in limiting very significant negative effects of the settlement of the agreements on the funds' finances. A considerable number of rulings have since confirmed that it was prudent to settle the agreements, as an acceptable outcome was achieved. The ruling in the Norvik case does not change that assessment.
Back to news